Can 1,000 Catholic priests be wrong?


Oliver Kamm

The question answers itself, but here’s the context.

More than 1,000 priests have signed a letter to the Telegraph protesting against same-sex marriage. They maintain that the Government’s forthcoming Equal Marriage Bill heralds a return to religious persecution. The Bishop of Portsmouth maintains that “it is quite Orwellian to try to redefine marriage”, and terms the proposed reform “totalitarian”.

It’s tempting to dismiss this as inflammatory nonsense, because that’s what it is. Even so, two points are worth drawing out.  

First, the clerical opponents of gay marriage continually commit the logical fallacy of begging the question (ie, assuming in their premises the truth of what they’re arguing for). They complain that the Government’s proposals “redefine marriage” – a redefinition that they are conscientiously and by Church teaching bound to oppose.

Yet the argument of the proponents of reform, including The Times, is explicitly that we are not redefining marriage. We merely seek to extend marriage rights to couples who are now barred from them on no better ground than that they are of the same sex. Reforming marriage to enable a woman to own property independently of her husband was a change of far greater scope than same-sex marriage will be. It was opposed on similar grounds of its supposedly being contrary to natural law. And it was obviously right and just. Same-sex marriage is a modest reform of similar type.

Second, because of that point, the Church will damage itself by the vitriol and hyperbole of its campaign. That’s a prediction, not a complaint – indeed it’s a scenario that I welcome and look forward to.

Damian Thompson, the prominent Catholic journalist, comments on his Telegraph blog that “David Cameron is at war not just with fundamentalists, but also with middle-of-the-road clergy and lay people from Britain’s largest and, arguably, best-integrated religious minority”.

I see no reason to doubt this, but draw the opposite inference. The war has been declared by the Church. Religious liberty is an axiom of a free society; but on public policy, the Church is a lobby like any other. It is not a repository of wisdom about the right and the true. Numerous Catholics implicitly acknowledge this by ignoring Pope Paul VI’s encyclical Humanae Vitae, proscribing artificial contraception.  

The history of civilisation is to a large extent bound up with separating religious from civic authority. By its obduracy, the Catholic Church is hastening the process.


  1. governmentproposals reblogged this from timesopinion
  2. onlytopnews reblogged this from timesopinion
  3. renegadehipsters reblogged this from timesopinion
  4. stschmuck reblogged this from timesopinion
  5. needtoknownews reblogged this from timesopinion and added:
    Marriage is not just an institution maintained by the church or even religion in this modern day. Marriage is...
  6. seentobedone reblogged this from timesopinion and added:
    It’s the first line of this that’s my favourite … but the rest is good too.
  7. tooprettytosmile reblogged this from timesopinion and added:
    baaaahhhhhh…I fucking hate Catholicism. The clergy should stop focusing on other peoples’ sex lives and instead stop...
  8. rainbowdynasty reblogged this from rheesusflux
  9. veggie-frenzee reblogged this from timesopinion
  10. 867t5309 reblogged this from timesopinion
  11. rheesusflux reblogged this from timesopinion
  12. danzithedragon reblogged this from pineapple-cube
  13. labsscrollsandstages reblogged this from timesopinion
  14. henotumbl reblogged this from timesopinion and added:
    Anyone who thinks it is Orwellian to allow gay marriage has clearly never read 1984
  15. pineapple-cube reblogged this from timesopinion
  16. felvagott reblogged this from timesopinion
  17. timesopinion posted this

Loading posts...